Be Excellent To Each Other

The corpses went in two by two...

Corpse one! Dismembered, blood everywhere, oh poor Goddess Jasmine!

Amidst the viscera lies a picture of Gazchap and some love letters. Goddess Jasmine was the other Townie Lover.


Corpse two! Shot in the back through a closed window. Someone took a hit out on Slightly Green.

His house is full of medical apparatus. Slightly Green was the Townie Doctor!

[playerlist]
DavPaz
Trooper
Malc
Craster
Ian Fairies
Bobbyaro
TheFireFaerie
Malc74
Nickachu
Grim...
TheVision
[/playerlist]

With eleven people remaining, six votes gets you a lynch.

Day ends at 10pm Monday night.

Just when you think you've turned a corner... BAM! townie apocalypse!

Well this is going quite horribly.

FOS list!
Malc
TheVision

Oh man, Kovacs was funny. I still don't think he knew why he died.

Someone smells very bad indeed. In fact, you all do.

Give me the cliff notes version of your FOSes, Craster, please.

TheVision - very quiet, said nothing at all committal.
Malc - everything he's written was dodgy in the extreme. GJ pointed the finger at him, GJ is dead.

wooOOOoooOOOOooo

Dead Thread Access pls


WeeeEEEeeeeEEEEEEEEeeeeeooooooooooo

Helped nail Mr Russ to the wall too, didn't he?

To add to that list: You, sir. You've been most quiet and you've only voted once.

And TFF, for belming so terribly.

I wanted to put after that first quote.

Oh, shit. I was certain that GJ was bad, absolutely certain. Fuck it.

Still, KovacsC gone is a bit of a result 2 mafia down, 2 more to go do we think?

I'm back to only being certain about Grim... and Nick again, this game is making me very fucking tired indeed!

I have been very quiet. Primarily because I didn't have any kind of fucking clue what was going on for all of day two.

p.s. in case anybody didn't catch it and needs it explaining, i'm really not the town princess, and Grim... isn't a cop

Not convinced that was a belm. She did put a vote in for Kovacs, but only pretty late when it was already pretty much too late to save him.

Sorry for not posting yesterday, i have just read it, my god that was the funniest thing I have read in ages!

Right my fosses so far are

TFF - SDG was sus of her earlier, as was I just the style of her posts, and yesterday she stalled as long as possible before putting the final vote in on kovacs.
Malc74 - I have agreed with a lot of what he has said, I am normally horrendously wrong, therefore ... .
DavPaz - just a niggling feeling.

Can someone let Kovac know!

Except this: viewtopic.php?p=722348#p722348

And this: viewtopic.php?p=722355#p722355
And this: viewtopic.php?p=722363#p722363

I'm saying it was deliberately attacking you to defend KC. No idea what the roleclaim quote was about.

This is pretty much my excuse too but I did contribute just so I wasn't bumped off as a quiet one.

Are you guys serious??? I voted for Squirt - bad guy, I didn't vote for Mr Russ - good guy, and I put the nail in Kov's coffin!

I wasn't stalling, just messing, I did say I was going to do it, but thought it might be funny (and fair on those wanting more time) to just let it run a while. A little like your Cop funny windup!! (Which yes, I did Belm on for a moment, then realised you were clearly dicking about)

It was about him pinning "Cop" on you, and it wasn't deliberate, was just curious, not 100% sure what was going on for a moment. I reiterate that I was the final Kov vote

He did?

I had admittedly forgotten that.

Was the Townie Doctor a power role? I don't see any description in the rules thread.

I don;t think TFF is bad, I think she was having a kovacsc moment.

I'm happy to be led by Grim... again, as he seems to be doing fucking well at the moment, TheVision maybe?

Fuck, I have literally no idea

Fixed!

I haven't had an idea since the game begun but that's normal for me in a scum game. I will say also, that the days seem to be starting pretty quick.

This means that all the power roles are getting their actions in during the day.

Do we have any evening posters left in the game? I'd say that if we do, then they don't have power roles.

Careful, that's verging on meta data.

Doesn't mean too much, though.

Once, no - but twice? I had her pegged as the Mafia don, but I think that's unlikely at this point.

Doesn't mean she isn't a mutant though, remember Gilly was after her.

Hmm - Gilly couldn't investigate though. Her role was basically hit and hope.

With no kill role, the Mutant Hunter is quite funny. It's less Buffy and more quietly taking a cheek swab while someone sleeps, analysing the result and quietly slipping away again. Dangerous, but hardly "AWOOOOOOOO!!!" dangerous

Could be the SK, though.

I can guarantee I'm neither!

Maybe I'm Rosaline...

Hold on to your hats people, analysis incoming!

What did every do the past 3 days?

Day 1

Voted for mafia kill
zaphod79, Ian Fairies, Alberto, Slightly Green, Mr Russell, Trooper, Craster, DavPaz, GazChap, TheFireFaerie, sdg

Voted against mafia kill
Grim..., Bobbyaro, nickachu, Malc74

Didn't vote
malc, kovacsc, goddess jasmine, thevision, squirt


Day 2

Voted for a good guy kill
Ian Fairies, nickachu, Trooper, Alberto, Malc, DavPaz, Slightly Green, TheVision, KovacsC

Voted against a good guy kill
Grim..., sdg, Malc74

Didn't vote
craster, mr russell, bobbyaro, thefirefaerie, goddess jasmine


Day 3

Voted for a mafia kill
Craster, Grim..., TheVision, Trooper, Ian Fairies, DavPaz, Slightly Green, TheFireFaerie

Voted against a mafia kill
Goddess Jasmine, Nickachu, KovacsC

Didn't vote
malc, bobbyaro, malc74





So, to summarise the people left...

DavPaz - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia
Trooper - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia
Malc - didn't vote, killed good guy, didn't vote
Craster - killed mafia, didn't vote, killed mafia
Ian Fairies - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia
Bobbyaro - didn't kill mafia, didn't vote, didn't vote
TheFireFaerie - killed mafia, didn't vote, killed mafia
Malc74 - didn't kill mafia, didn't kill good guy, didn't vote
Nickachu - didn't kill mafia, killed good guy, didn't kill mafia
Grim... - didn't kill mafia, didn't kill good guy, killed mafia
TheVision - didn't vote, killed good guy, killed mafia



Let's crunch some numbers and give each action a number of points. I think it is fair to say actively doing something is worse than passively not doing something, so I think this scoring system works?

Killed mafia = +2
Killed good guy = -2
didn't kill mafia = -1
didn't kill good guy = +1
didn't vote = 0


Which gives us...

DavPaz - +4
Trooper - +4
Malc - -2
Craster - +4
Ian Fairies - +4
Bobbyaro - -1
TheFireFaerie - +4
Malc74 - 0
Nickachu - -4
Grim... - +2
TheVision - 0


And in order of evilness, from top to bottom...

Nickachu - -4
Malc - -2
Bobbyaro - -1
Malc74 - 0
TheVision - 0
Grim... - +2
DavPaz - +4
Trooper - +4
Craster - +4
Ian Fairies - +4
TheFireFaerie - +4

Are we so sure that Nickachu is good? If so, he is the iest of any good guy out there
Giving him the benefit of the doubt for now...

[vote: malc]

I don't even know where to start with that nonsense!

Wow.. you can't argue with maths!

There are none so blind as those that can't see.
Scared because you came out third on the list are we?

Yeah, but who came out top, and then you didn't vote for him. Basically, it is meaningless.

It's a guide, nothing more. Nickachu has pretty much been proved good, hasn't he? If anyone wants to argue that he hasn't then i'm happy to listen and switch my vote to him.
For the rest of the people we are unsure about, then it is a better guide than the random crap wh have been slinging about.

I'm 50:50 on you by the way, your roleclaim never got counterclaimed, so you could be ok.

Either way, we know fuck all about malc, and he is first on the evil list of people we know fuck all about.

Hmmm

Not sure I like that, not sure I like that at all.

I'd more be looking at the people who voted for everyone!

Those are the people who don't care who they kill.

YEs they've killed 2 mafia, but that was through luck than skill!

I would suggest the mutants and sk are in the group of people who voted all three times for the person who hanged.

DavPaz - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia
Trooper - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia
Ian Fairies - killed mafia, killed good guy, killed mafia

Those 3!

so

[vote:trooper]

Malc

Let me get this straight, your argument is that people who have killed 2 mafia must be bad? And you, who have done nothing other than kill a good guy, are good?

Awesome argument, and then you follow up with a counter vote for me out of those three listed. Hit a little too close to home did I

Whoops, just realised I did sums wrong, new list incoming!

I thought as much...

And in order of evilness, from top to bottom...

Nickachu - -4
Malc - -2
Bobbyaro - -1
Malc74 - 0
TheVision - 0
Grim... - +2
DavPaz - +2
Trooper - +2
Ian Fairies - +2
Craster - +4
TheFireFaerie - +4

Doesn't change much at all in the ordering of evilness, luckily.

That's not my argument at all.

My argument is that there was no way of knowing that Squirt was bad when he as voted, and kovacs wasn't voted out because he was bad, he was voted out because his lack of understanding was driving people mad.

All three votes have ended whilst I've been working and haven't been able to add or subtract my vote.

I only voted for Russell because of your suggestion, I was initially going after Jazzy.

So it might look like I've voted in a scummy way, it's really been bad luck the way they have gone.

The fact that you are overlooking what I said and trying to simplify it makes me think *I* hit close to home!

The vote stays

Malc

What?!

[vote:malc]

Great counter argument again.
"I'm not bad, I was originally voting for this other good person, see!"

@malc Kovacs was voted out because he was tricked into making a completely bogus roleclaim by confirmed townies.