Be Excellent To Each Other

Apologies for the brevity and lack of colour, pushed for time

Joans has been arrested! Poor Joans

Flis has bitten the big one, with a big old smile on her face.
Flis was an innocent bystander

Alarm was found thing morning, glasses all crooked and a lump of weird green rock stuffed in his mouth.
Alarm was Superman Oh no!


Jail rules reminder:
A jailed person will have access to the jail thread and will be able to publicly communicate with everyone in jail via that thread.
Normal non-jailed players cannot see the jail thread
A jailed person can choose to privately communicate with whoever they want who is also in jail.
A jailed person can still communicate in the main thread.
A jailed person can still vote.
A jailed person has no night actions.
A jailed person is immune from night actions.
Roles are not revealed when arrested.
Jailed players still keep their win conditions.
If the Jailor is killed, all jailed players are released and go back to their original ruleset.
A jailed person can still be lynched.


[Playerlist]
GazChap
goddess jasmine
gospvg
Grim...
Joans
Jon.J
kalmar
KovacsC
Mr Russell
sinister agent
Slightly Green
[/playerlist]

Jailed List
Slightly Green
GazChap
Joans

Rules
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=6834

Deadline
As before, due to me being away for the weekend, from mid morning today to Sunday afternoon, Day 4 will be super long and end 2pm Monday.
Depending on 3G access and phone battery I should be able to check in at random times, and if there is a lynch, tell you the role and call for night actions, but if a mod can keep an eye and lock the thread should the voting end early, that would be appreciated.

With 11 players alive, 6 votes are required for a lynch, and 8 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.
http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

Can a mod do the deed with the jail list and dead list permission? Ta.

Superman is dead - FUCK !!

Quick thanks to Russ for starting off the lynching of Curiosity
Let us know what info you have today?

Blimey, well at least we know that batman is on the level, Thanks Mr R. Ohh noes Superman has been clobbered. Will think about this over coffee

That means we only have LL and the Joker left...

SA your radar seems off, how is arresting Brianiac better than lynching him.

Why were you so against a lynch? FOS=SA

Blimey. I have to go to work in a min and obviously want to wait and see what Russ says. I'll post properly later when I'm at my pc.

Aye since we have one dead bad guy, and 2 kills from them last night then that kinda puts Gaz in the clear, so unless he is a henchman then we have 3 good guys in jail, if Joans was a killer he would have been blocked by being arrested.....so our list of suspects grows

Slightly Green - good
GazChap - good
Joans - good
Mr Russell - Batman

goddess jasmine
gospvg
Grim...
Jon.J
kalmar
KovacsC
sinister agent

So out of the 7 people left we have Lex, Joker for the bad. Robin (if not in jail), Jailer, Policeman and innocents.
This is all assuming that no henchmen are left which would throw a spanner in the works a little, but not much as if they are on their own then they are just evil bystanders who will be pushing to lynch good guys.

Since Mr R has proven himself and knows who Robin is and at lest one other from his comments yesterday, hopefully 2 with last nights action, i suggest we follow his finger pointing today, even if he knows 2 innocents and robin he has much better odds of hitting bad guys than a random vote.

Depends on who he investigated yesterday?

Also anyone in jail could be evil because they can't use night actions

Bah. I obviously tried to protect Mr Russell last night. See you on the other side. At least I'll be reunited with Superdog.

Be not alarmed, indeed!

Maybe a henchman in jail.

Well, truth be told, this being in jail lark isn't all that bad. Three squares a day, and I'm safe from all of you murderous psychopaths.

Am I in the clear now? Genius move by the real Brainiac to try and pass suspicion on to me, I have to say.

Isn't that a secondary win condition? We just need to get the big bad guys...

Sure, but if we lynch the jailer they come out of jail again.

Obviously we wait for Dinner.

Dinner

Dinner

Dinner

BATMAN

* groan*

Yes if all the bad guys are in jail & the Jailer is alive we win

True but the police seem to be playing proper numptys at the moment in my humble opinion, at least its nice and safe in here.

Still have my doubts about gospvg, FOS as he seems to be missing logic and any vague grasp of this games rules/player ability's.

No I'm getting the hang of it now, my logic might be a bit screwed but like everyone else its guesswork trying to figure out who is good/evil

Out of Slightly Green's list, I would like to know who each of these people think we should lynch today:

goddess jasmine
gospvg
Grim...
Jon.J
kalmar
KovacsC
sinister agent

I am sus of Sinister, but I think that's just because he's been loud.
No-one else is really hitting my sus-o-meter, so I'm going to go for GJ.

Did you investigate anyone yesterday?

Um, why are we trusting Slightly Green's list again?

I assume Russ knows his role?

I think the point is he doesn't want to tell us, so he probably got an innocent.

Right, fair enough.

Because he reasoned that the bad guys have still killed, and a bad guy in jail wouldn't have been able to kill.

I investigated a person who turned out to be innocent last night.

But surely everyone who is in jail can't be good?

There may be a henchman in there, but as they can't do anything, we can leave them for later.

Ok I know I'm good so I say like grim we go for Jasmine but don't lynch her until she has a chance to reply

Agreed all evil guys in jail is still good.

Weird that Lex chose to kill Superman rather than convert him.

I want to know how he knew. He's only got one shot at getting it right, after all.

There was only one kill on night one, so I reckon he got lucky. With us killing off brainiac, the only other super character, he must have known that his kill that didn't succeed was turned into a roleblock, and it must have been on superman.

Erm, I assume I'm not meant to be able to post here? Unless dead players just don't post because they are dead.

I'm super, thanks for asking. See you on the other side.

I am personally quite suspicious of the people who rush-voted yesterday, despite the fact that at least three people explicitly asked that we wait so that other people could catch up on the day's events.

Also the other quiet people, still. Admittedly, Alarm was very quiet, but we still have a few people who aren't saying much. It would be nice to know what they're thinking.

It seems a pretty safe bet that Russ is Batbloke, obv.

Russ - Who are you planning to investigate next? Or are you going to do something else? If you'd rather not answer, fair enough, but we should probably make a plan now so we can make the best use of the lynch and the cop.

That's the gist of it.
Shh!

It was him:

Oh, and I meant to add (sorry, am being distracted a lot) that this exactly is what Curio did to Davpaz.

Rather than be all insinuate-y, I hereby befinger my suspicions at Gospvg, who's also been listing people as good/evil with little justification, playing the newbie card a lot, and now gunning for Jasmine after previously declaring her to be good.

If you opt for me then who will help you with your plan?

"plan now so we can make the best use of the lynch and the cop"

gospvg has also been giving me dubious vibes.

That post may not have been a good idea, but I'll take it at face value for now.

In that case, I am unsure of who to focus our attention on, so apart from falling back on "provoke the quiet people", don't really know what to suggest.

explain? how?

Yes I think we need to get the quieter people talking, with Trooper away this weekend.
We have enough time to take a look at everyone.

Three people did say wait, but it turned out that he was a evil..

What would have been the benefit of waiting?

It came down to Russ being Batman, believe him or not.

So SA unless you are trying to move focus away from he baddies, what is your plan?

Yesterday, we didn't know that Russell was on the level. If his roleclaim were fake, one of the quiet people might have been Batman/Robin and wouldn't have had time to react. Or one of the people who asked for us to hold back until they could catch up could have been a power role who needed to read the thread before deciding whether to claim/protect etc.

Rush lynching is almost never a good idea - especially with an untested role claim.





And if you go from 'roleclaim' to 'lynch' before someone can even get home from work and read through the thread, several people will not have time to decide what to believe.




Like I said above, I don't really have one. I have a couple of vague suspicions, but we probably all do, and without Batman taking the lead (which I understand may not be an option as last night's target was innocent) don't know what to suggest besides provoking the quiet people to see if more information comes out.