Be Excellent To Each Other

Crippled by fear and self loathing, the town did nothing, they cried shamefully into their beds and thought back to the day before.
Why didn't I say anything, why didn't I speak up, why am I such a wuss?

Well, not everyone was in bed last night...

Death 1
Malc is dead! Oh no!
Malc was a breast obsessed Townie everything he said was a boob euphemism of some kind

Death 2
Joans is dead! Oh no! Oh no!
Joans was the mafia don!.... No wait, that isn't right, sorry again... Joans was a Serial Killer!



[playerlist]
Alarm
ApplePieOfDestiny
Bobbyaro
Curiosity
DavPaz
ElephantBanjoGnome
flis
Goddess Jasmine
KovacsC
nickachu
sinister agent
[/playerlist]

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

Link to Ruleset: viewtopic.php?f=8&t=7446

With 11 players alive, 6 votes are required for a lynch, and 8 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

Day 4 Ends at 2pm Wednesday

Don't forget the dead thread mods...

Boobs!



Ma...erk

Hmmm... it says "a" Serial Killer, not "the".

Two SKs in the town? That would blow mightily.

And another Townie down. We'd best hope the Mafia is small.

Three nights for the cop to have done some good work though. With so few people and so many kill roles, we're lucky he's survived, and hopefully has info.

This is a good point, I've just looked at the rules and there are no possible numbers next to the roles.

We could do with some governance in this town, we're losing townies like sand through our fingers.

This is madness. Perhaps there is more than one investigator if the roles are mad. So do we beleive that two mafia are dead or is something really odd going on?

This is madness. Perhaps there is more than one investigator if the roles are mad. So do we beleive that two mafia are dead or is something really odd going on?

Looks like something really odd is going on... at least with your net connection!

[Vote:Goddess Jasmine]

You're evil, bebeh.

My theory: There is someone who is specifically aiming to kill the mafia boss.

This is good on the face of it, but if they actually do hit the mafia boss, we should probably assume they've become the new one and so aren't really on our side.

Interesting that we're down to two again. It looks like either someone roleblocked two different killers (there was no 'mafia don... oh wait' kill on night one), or the doctor protected two targets. Either way, good work.

This could actually be the turning point, because unless we lynch a mafia-er today, we might go under completely if the SK also fails to kill a mafia type. But we've lynched precisely nobody so far, and unless something dramatic happens I doubt this will change.

So. A first.

I'm the hooker. On night one I blocked Malc, using my unfeasibly large head. On night two I blocked Goddess Jasmine. J. On night three I blocked Malc again (to see if we'd have one less kill again).

So, two things:

1) Doc - unless our killers failed to strike, you must have saved two lives already. Consider what this might mean. I don't advise you to roleclaim, but you may think better.

2) Cop, I don't know whether you should come forward yet - depends on what you've found. But you should definitely consider it.

3) Doc, please protect me tonight, or I'm dead.

Oh, er, that was only going to be two things when I started, but is obviously now three. I was up very late, alright?

Sorry I've been quiet, I've been catching up on homework for school. I agree with SA that there may be an undisclosed extra role trying to hit the Don.

I'd like a clarification on ebg's gj vote if possible

So there are 11 of us left.

I am guessing :-
1 Hooker (SA Role Claim)
1 Doctor
1 SK (?) or similar.
1 Loony
1 Cop
1-3 Mafia Depending on what we started with

So that leaves 3 to 5 (depending on Mafia) Townies.

That is assuming that the cop isn't also a "mafia, oh no he isn't" I don't understand wh\t is going on with that "mafia ..." stuff.

I am wondering if EBG has some info on GJ though?

What isour biggest threat the mafia or the sk at the moment?

I don't know, but can we assume that the "mafia..." have actually lost anyone? or is this just a wind-up? Because if they have then they have lost 2 now, so that can't leave that many left. Does this mean that joans had a dual killing role? We'll see tomorrow how many kills happen and can try and make sense of it then?

So what you are saying is do nothing again?

I strongly suspect Nickachu of being Mafia.

No. Absoultly not. We need to get rid of the Mafia or the "other SK" or whatever they are.

And also, I was keen on doing something on day 2. A lot more than anyone else, now with SA's claim of being the Hooker, if it's true then I was wrong, but at least I was trying to get something done to actually learn something. So far we've learnt nothing, some action is required to make sense of it all.

Well yes.. but as you referred to seeing who died tonight!

(sorry I am able to post today so I might be on a lot)

I was saying that we can see if Joans had a dual killing role tonight by looking at the number of kills, we would learn something that way, I wasn't saying, oh we should just sit around and do nothing, just saying that there was something to be learnt there.

Come on you lot talk!!!

I don't know what all the "Mafia" stuff means but to be honest, I am suspicious of Kov for picking up on it before it was even on anyone else's radar....

Other than you, I'd be happy to go for a quiet person, seems like if they allow themselves to be voted off with n defence, they're not worth keeping around anyway.

My only problem is that the two people I want to lynch are the two people talking, and I feel bad about that.

I am happy to discuss things, as long as we talk..

Otherwise it will be an SK win as we will time out again. We times out with a 3 day 'day' over the weekend..

so the seriel killer is ded but ppl think there may b another1?
it isnt looking 2 good for us

Everyone remains quiet and reluctant to vote.

I feel a Mafia win coming on (and possibly an SK win too... I assume that an SK win doesn't end the town entirely).

I'm not sure what the cop knows, but the doctor seems to have been doing a good job to protect a couple of times. I think they should keep on doing their thing.

Anyway, let's get a lynch on.

[vote:nickachu]

Anyone care to agree/disagree?

Why are you so certain that the SK will win, as far as I can tell no mafia have actually been killed so far.

[vote: Applepieofdestiny]

Erm well this awkward.

Explain.

What is?

If he doesn't explain something soon I'm going to vote for him, the tall bastard.

I am an undercover cop, deep inside the Mafia.. so I let it slip when the first mafia don was killed. There are two mafia left me and Alarm.

I can't kill hence there was no mafia kill last night.

How can I convince you I am a cop...? Alarm has to go!!

[Vote:alarm]

I have done 3 investigations....

You do realise that we can't check that you are telling the truth? My own fault I admit, I regretted that post as soon as I had made it. But never mind.

I agree about this extra role to hit the Don, can we then assume that they would then become the Don?


From looking back at yesterday, he's not really making much sense, he posted:



Also, if SA is telling the truth, he would have role blocked me on night two, when there were three kills. So if I was a baddy, I don't know what other role he thinks I might have had.

Followed by;


So how many mafia do you think there are then..? You've gone from 1-3 to a definite 2. If you are a cop don't you get to investigate? Suspecting just another fishy roleclaim here.

What? Seriously? You are a deep undercover cop in the mafia, so the mafia know who you are, but think you are mafia, so you have had communication with the mafia from day one?

You need to give us more than that though.

of which he is a definite one!

Yes..

There was 4 of us to start of with, i was vague when i put the list out as I was not sure I would role claim.

I discovered two town win conditions and who the loony is!!

Yup!

But I am a cop,hence we did not kill last night, as I was ordered to kill but I can't... so my win condition is Town now!


I am dead either way..

So, are you going to tell us who you investigated?

Kovacs:

1) Tell us who you investigated
2) Why didn't you just let us know who the Mafia are at the start?

I can do, would it be best to out the loony?

yes so we keep in game and they lose lol!!!
this is messed up yeah

It would narrow down our list of people who could be the remaining serial killer (assuming that there is one, and that you're telling the truth), so go for it.

ElephantBanjoGnome is the loony!!